News Updates[S. 311 CrPC] Accused Has A Right To Summon Any Evidence/Witness Relevant For Proper Appreciation Of Prosecution Evidence: Allahabad High Court [Read Order] LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK3 Nov 2020 4:03 AMShare This – xIn a significant order, the Allahabad High Court allowed an application for recall of witness moved by an accused under Section 311 of CrPC, while holding that the same is a matter of right, when it comes to proper appreciation of the prosecution evidence. “There can be no dispute that the accused has a right to summon any evidence/witness which may be relevant for proper…Your free access to Live Law has expiredTo read the article, get a premium account.Your Subscription Supports Independent JournalismSubscription starts from ₹ 599+GST (For 6 Months)View PlansPremium account gives you:Unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments.Reading experience of Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.Subscribe NowAlready a subscriber?LoginIn a significant order, the Allahabad High Court allowed an application for recall of witness moved by an accused under Section 311 of CrPC, while holding that the same is a matter of right, when it comes to proper appreciation of the prosecution evidence. “There can be no dispute that the accused has a right to summon any evidence/witness which may be relevant for proper appreciation of the prosecution evidence and to substantiate his defence, therefore, in any case when the mobile and pen drive have already been exhibited in the record, then, recall of the injured witness appears to be necessary for his re-examination by the defence on the question of that video clip,” the Single Bench of Justice Rajiv Joshi held. The power to summon material witness, or examine person present under Section 311 of CrPC stipulates that any Court may, at any stage of any inquiry, trial or other proceeding under this Code, summon any person as a witness, or examine any person in attendance, though not summoned as a witness, or. recall and re- examine any person already examined; and the Court shall summon and examine or recall and re- examine any such person if his evidence appears to it to be essential to the just decision of the case. The Court noted that it is settled law that the power of recall has to be exercised with “caution and circumspection” and reasons for exercising this power should be spelt out in the order. “Mere observation that recall was necessary “for ensuring fair trial” is not enough unless there are tangible reasons to show how the fair trial suffered without recall. Recall is not a matter of course and the discretion given to the court has to be exercised judiciously to prevent failure of justice and not arbitrarily,” the Supreme Court had held in State (NCT of Delhi) v. Shiv Kumar Yadav & Anr., (2016) 2 SCC 402. In the case at hand, the Court observed, it was essential to recall the witness, as sought for by the Applicant, so he may be re-examined in light of the video clip produced by the applicant during Defence Evidence. The Court took note of the Applicant’s submission that the accused had the opportunity to produce the video clip under Section 233 of CrPC, only after recording of statement under Section 313 CrPC, and not before that. Therefore, further examination of the witness in question was necessary for the purpose of confronting his statement contained in the video clip in which he had disclosed the names of actual accused persons, who had committed the offence. The Court observed that the Trial Court was in error in rejecting the Applicant’s application for bail on the ground that the application has been moved just to delay the trial. “When the accused-applicant is in jail, therefore, there is also no occasion to delay the proceeding of the trial,” the Bench said. It further observed, “So far as the observation made by the trial court that the said application is without the list of questionnaire is concerned, it is firstly stated that there is no requirement under the law to file questionnaire along with the application for recalling the witness and secondly that it is clearly mentioned in the application under section 311,Cr.P.C. itself that injured witness P.W.-5 Nitin is to be summoned with regard to the contents of his video clip.” Accordingly, the Court directed the Trial Court to recall the witness in question, at an early date. The Application in this case was accused under Section 302, 307, 201, 376D, 394, 411 and 120 IPC and section ¾ POCSO Act, 2012, for rape and murder of a minor girl and for causing injury to her brother. Case Title: Amarjeet @ Kaluwa v. State of UP & Anr. Click Here To Download Order Read OrderSubscribe to LiveLaw, enjoy Ad free version and other unlimited features, just INR 599 Click here to Subscribe. All payment options available.loading….Next Story
Equal Opportunity Employer/Protected Veterans/Individuals withDisabilities.Please view Equal Employment Opportunity Posters provided byOFCCP here .The contractor will not discharge or in any other mannerdiscriminate against employees or applicants because they haveinquired about, discussed, or disclosed their own pay or the pay ofanother employee or applicant. However, employees who have accessto the compensation information of other employees or applicants asa part of their essential job functions cannot disclose the pay ofother employees or applicants to individuals who do not otherwisehave access to compensation information, unless the disclosure is(a) in response to a formal complaint or charge, (b) in furtheranceof an investigation, proceeding, hearing, or action, including aninvestigation conducted by the employer, or (c) consistent with thecontractor’s legal duty to furnish information. 41 CFR60-1.35(c) Physician – PulmonaryWest Virginia University School of Medicine and the Department ofMedicine seeks multiple Pulmonary Physicians (ranks available:Assistant Professor, Associate Professor, or Professor). Thesuccessful candidate will be expected to practice in the primarylocation of Uniontown, PA.Successful candidate may also be assigned to provide services atother worksites, including but not necessarily limited to, WestVirginia University Hospitals, Inc., West Virginia UniversityMedical Corporation doing business as “University HealthAssociates,” [etc.] located in West Virginia, Maryland, andPennsylvania and, as such, travel is anticipated and expected tofulfill said duties at these other worksitesDuties: The successful candidate will practice in the areas ofPulmonary Medicine. In addition to providing excellent patientcare, the successful candidate will also be actively involved inteaching medical students, residents, and fellows. Will offeroutpatient pulmonary clinic, inpatient pulmonary consults, performbronchoscopies and read pulmonary function tests For appointment atthe Associate Professor or Professor rank, it is expected thatcandidates sustain an outstanding, extramurally supported researchprogram.Qualifications: applicants must have a MD or DO degree or foreignequivalent and be eligible to obtain unrestricted Pennsylvania andWest Virginia medical licenses. Candidates must be board certifiedor eligible in Pulmonary Diseases at the time of appointment. Forappointment at the Associate Professor or Professor rank, ademonstrated track-record of leadership, excellent communicationskills, and publications in high-impact journals are required. Allqualifications must be met by the time of appointment.WVU Medicine is West Virginia University’s affiliated healthsystem, West Virginia’s largest private employer, and a nationalleader in patient safety and quality. The WVU Health System iscomprised of eleven member hospitals and five hospitals undermanagement agreements, anchored by its flagship hospital, J.W RubyMemorial Hospital in Morgantown, a 700+ bed academic medical centerthat offers tertiary and quaternary care. WVU Medicine has morethan 1,000 active medical staff members and 18,000 employees whoserve hundreds of thousands of people each year from across thestate of West Virginia and the nation.Uniontown Hospital is a compassionate, dedicated community hospitalproviding a full range of medical care to residents of FayetteCounty and the surrounding areas for more than a century. Healthcare services provided at our acute and specialty care hospitalinclude an award-winning Cardiology Department and catheterizationlab, an award-winning Stroke Center, and a state-of-the-art WoundHealing Center.Build your legacy as you serve, teach, learn and make a differencefrom day one. To learn more, https://wvumedicine.org/criticalcare/and apply online at http://wvumedicine.org/careersFor additional questions, please contact Angel Greathouse [email protected] Virginia University & University Health Associates are anAA/EO employer – Minority/Female/Disability/Veteran – and WVU isthe recipient of an NSF ADVANCE award for gender equity.